Why Some Men Cheat — And What It Has to Do with “Wifey Material”

You ever wonder how a man can build a whole life with you — the family, the vacations, the home — and still betray you like it meant nothing?

You’re not alone.
And no, you’re not the problem.

Let’s talk about a term that might help explain why some men cheat — and why so many women spend their lives trying to walk an impossible tightrope.

🧠 The Madonna/Whore Complex: What It Is

Coined by Freud (yes, that Freud), the Madonna/Whore Complex describes a mindset where some men split women into two rigid categories:

  • The Madonna — pure, nurturing, modest, self-sacrificing. “Wife material.”

  • 🔥 The Whore — sexual, seductive, passionate, free. But never “the one.”

In this binary, women can be loved or desired — but never both.

It’s a psychological theory, yes.
But it’s also a social script that’s been reinforced for generations.

🧨 Why This Is Bigger Than Just Psychology

The Madonna/Whore Complex didn’t appear out of nowhere.
It’s a tool of patriarchy — reinforced by systems like colonialism, Christianity, and capitalism — all of which have punished women for being autonomous, sexual, or complex.

This binary keeps women small and divided.
It tells us there’s one right way to be a woman — and anything else is dangerous.

And it shows up everywhere:

  • 📰 Jackie vs. Marilyn — the poised wife vs. the sex symbol mistress

  • 📰 Beyoncé vs. Rihanna — the respectable icon vs. the rebellious muse

(And don’t even get me started on what happens when race, body type, and class enter the mix.)

💔 The Emotional Fallout for Women

If you’ve ever felt like you weren’t “wife material” because you enjoy your body, your freedom, or your ambition — this is why.

If you’ve ever been praised for being a “good woman” but felt unseen, unheard, and exhausted — this is why.

If you’ve ever watched a man praise you in public, but pursue someone else in private — this is why.

The Madonna/Whore Complex isn’t just sexist — it’s unsustainable.
It leaves women performing for impossible standards and men unable to engage with women as whole human beings.

🙅🏽‍♀️ What “Wifey Material” Really Means

At its core, “wifey material” is not a compliment.
It’s a coded demand to be palatable, nonthreatening, respectable — in ways that prop up fragile masculinity.

It asks women to contort into a version of themselves that makes men feel more comfortable.

And here’s the problem:
When men only know how to categorize women — not connect with them —
they often seek sexual freedom elsewhere, because they can’t reconcile desire with respect.

It’s not right. But it’s real.
And it’s why some men cheat, even when they love you.

✨ You Are Allowed to Be the Whole You

You don’t have to choose between being loved and being desired.

You don’t have to:

  • Shrink to be “chosen”

  • Censor your sensuality

  • Be quiet to be respected


    You’re allowed to be:

  • Soft and sexy

  • Smart and sexual

  • Desired and deserving of devotion

    Because the truth is: you were never the problem.
    This outdated system is.

💬 Ready to Dig Deeper?

If this lit something up in you — anger, grief, clarity, or freedom — come explore it with me.

I teach all of this (and more) inside my live virtual workshop:

Single, Empowered, & Free

🖤 For Black & Brown women tired of shrinking themselves
🖤 Rooted in psychology, liberation, and sisterhood
🖤 $97 | 2 hours | No replays — because presence is power

👉🏾 Register Here

P.S. Part 2 of this series explores how this mindset doesn’t just affect our dating lives — but our friendships too.

Because when patriarchy teaches us to compete instead of connect, sisterhood becomes a threat instead of a refuge.

Fanny Tristan, LCSW-R

Fanny Tristan, LCSW-R, is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker, Women's Empowerment Coach, and Founder of Her Soul Supply, a coaching platform designed to help women of color embrace their singlehood with confidence. With over 15 years of experience specializing in break-up recovery and trauma-focused psychotherapy, she helps women break free from societal pressures and create supportive and loving communities. Her work has supported hundreds of women in redefining self-worth, setting boundaries, and creating freedom and happiness in their single era. Learn more at HerSoulSupply.com.

https://hersoulsupply.com
Next
Next

 How to have a happy and healthy heaux season